Aries: Chocolate whoopie cake

Taurus: Apple pie

Gemini: Pumpkin pie

Cancer: Anything vegan

Leo: Orange Dreamsicle cake

Virgo: Grasshopper bars

Libra: Nutella/strawberry cream puffs

Scorpio: Gooey butter cake

Sagittarius: Surprise cake

Capricorn: Sugar cookies

Aquarius: Chocolate lasagna

Pisces: Orange poppy seed cookies